Pedra branca, the size of a football field, is 40km east of singapore. Nus law schools faculty members analyse the icjs ruling on pedra branca associate professor simon tay comments on pedra branca. But the basic mission of international law remains the facilitation of peaceful dispute resolution. Malaysia to reconsider its challenge to icj judgment on. Horsburgh lighthouse, built over 150 years ago, is the oldest here.
Collection of advisory opinions 19231930 series ab. The icj was requested to determine whether sovereignty over a pedra branca. Sitting at the eastern entrance of the straits of singapore, the island is important for both countries. Pedra branca s location 24 nautical miles east of singapore and eight nautical miles south of johor is seen as strategic as it lies in the eastern approach to a. Malaysia has withdrawn its applications to revise and to interpret a 2008 judgment by the international court of justice that awarded sovereignty of pedra branca. Singapore and malaysia discuss implementation of icj.
Pedra branca dispute, the impasse on the implementation of the poa, the problems over the central provident funds cpf of malaysians, johor water agreements, and the construction of a scenic bridge to replace the causeway. What the world is missing april 24, 2020 covid19 strategy. Cambodiathailand, the south china sea, and the role of international law simon chesterman, vice dean and professor, faculty of law, national university of singapore. Lecturer faculty of science and it school of design, communication and it dr. Singapore, namely pedra brancapulau batu puteh, middle rocks and south ledge. The dispute began in 1979 and was largely resolved by the international court of justice icj in 2008. It describes how the two countries managed the dispute over three decades until final resolution by the international court of justice in may 2008. Pedra brancapulau batu puteh is a granite island, measur ing 7 m long, with an average width of 60 m and covering an area of about 8,560 sq m at low tide. The case was formally registered by the icj as the case concerning sovereignty over pedra branca pulau batu puteh, middle rocks and south ledge malaysiasingapore. It points out that in its territorial dispute with indonesia, when it occupied the contested islands, malaysia employed the same status quo position. Why did pedra branca only become an issue in 1979, and why. This is a very interesting account of the singapore side of the story of how the case with malaysia concerning the sovereignty over pedra branca, a tiny island strategically located near the entrance to the straits of malacca, went to. In the background, at left and right, are a pair of outcrops called middle rocks. Judgments sovereignty over pedra brancapulau batu puteh.
Pedra branca comprises two adjacent high grade, steeply dipping coppergold deposits, east and west pbe and pbw. Located approximately 40 kilometers off eastern singapore, malaysia had staked a claim to pedra branca as it published a map of its territorial waters and continental shelf boundaries, back in 1979. Whats next for the malaysiasingapore pedra branca dispute. Why malaysia is fighting singapore over a rock south. But this is not so in this case between malaysia and singapore, in which the court held that the critical date for pedra branca was 14 february 1980, and 6 february 1993 for middle rocks and south ledge. Pedra branca pulau batu puteh is a granite island, measur ing 7 m long, with an average width of 60 m and covering an area of about 8,560 sq m at low tide. The prolong dispute over pedra branca between singapore and malaysia.
Latest developments sovereignty over pedra brancapulau. Sovereignty over pedra brancapulau batu puteh, middle rocks. Pdf this paper discusses on the issues related to batu puteh island pedra branca which is a topic of discussion in relation to the sovereignty of a. Hessel gerritsz, map of sumatra showing pedra branca. Ministry of foreign affairs singapore pedra branca. Uss mccain collision exposes singaporemalaysia sea dispute. Remarkably, many of these longstanding bones of contention were swiftly and. Malaysia drops challenge to icj ruling on pedra branca cna. Singapore claimed that they had exercised authority over batu putih by managing a lighthouse there, requiring malaysian officials to obtain permits to visit the island and building a military broadcast station in the late 1970s. They added that the icj would have been forced to, reach a different conclusion on the question of sovereignty over pedra branca pulau batu puteh had it been aware of this new evidence.
History is on our side the conflict in 1979 was also stirred because malaysia submitted a map depicting pulau batu puteh, the malay term for white rock and hence pedra branca, as within its territory. The international court of justice and territorial. Pedra branca is a multicultural project and develops a creative concept of making world music together with brazilian and contemporary music. Singapore sent a diplomatic note 14 february 1980 asking that the map be corrected. Detail of a map of sumatra showing the island of pedrablanca pedra branca by hessel gerritz, a cartographer of the hydrographic service of the dutch east india company.
The dispute began in 1979 and was largely resolved by the international court of justice. So,what better alternative than to bring closure to an issue that could have undermined asean solidarity between malaysia and singapore. Feb 11, 2017 on 21 december 1979 malaysia published a map where pedra branca was within malaysias territorial waters. A lesson learnt from the case of batu puteh island pedra branca. Pedra branca s location 24 nautical miles east of singapore and eight nautical miles south of johor is seen as strategic as it lies in the eastern approach to a key sea channel leading. Malaysia gets middle rocks pdf, the straits times reproduced on the national university of singapore newshub website, pp. Story of the unheard cases, shows how singapore prepared to counter malaysias applications for a revision and interpretation of the. Jan, 2017 sleeps four adults plus two small children in portable cot and foldaway bed. Even in the pedra branca case, the icj tried to keep everyone happy. This book is about the territorial dispute between malaysia and singapore over pedra branca, a small but strategically located island near the entrance to the straits of malacca. Case note on the question of admissibility 2017 2 perth international law journal 62 63 both houses of the federal parliament.
The pedra branca dispute 2008 icj 2 was a territorial dispute between singapore and malaysia over several islets at the eastern entrance to the singapore strait, namely pedra branca previously. A case study of singaporean and malaysian print media during the pedra branca territorial dispute jiayu queek faculty of science and it school of design, communication and it mr paul scott b. World court says disputed isle belongs to singapore reuters. The issue is a dispute over the sovereignty of the pedra branca island, which lies 4. Acts and documents relating to judgments and advisory opinions given by the court pleadings, oral arguments and documents.
Nov 23, 2014 the pedra branca dispute 2008 icj 2 was a territorial dispute between singapore and malaysia over several islets at the eastern entrance to the singapore strait, namely pedra branca previously. It was born at the turn of the century, with new technolog. The argument for pedra branca can also be applied to the dispute over original title to middle rocks and. Sovereignty over pedra brancapulau batu puteh, middle.
Under the terms of that special agreement, the parties requested the court to determine whether sovereignty over. Lim, lydia 24 may 2008, pedra branca belongs to singapore. The special agreement a formal agreement that was needed for the submission of the dispute to the icj was signed on 6th february 2003 by the foreign ministers of both countries, and formally notified to the icj on 24 july 2003. Malaysia closes pedra branca case, so singapore team goes. The name means white rock in portuguese portuguese pronunciation. Therefore, the court had to determine the sovereignty of middle rocks. An analysis of the underlying factors that affected malaysia. Summaries of judgments, advisory opinions and orders of the. Pedra branca dispute project gutenberg selfpublishing. The dispute between malaysia and singapore over pedra branca, middle rocks and south ledge three maritime features located at the eastern entrance of the straits of singapore began in december 1979 when malaysia published a map depicting pedra branca as lying within its territorial waters. May 26, 2017 pedra branca prefeasibility study pedra branca is avanco s second and much larger project, located 50km straight line southwest of the producing antas mine. World court ends 28year dispute, declaring main island is singapores. The dispute began in 1979 and was resolved by the international court of justice in 2008, which opined that pedra branca belonged to singapore and middle rocks belonged to.
Pedra branca for over 150 years since the british occupation and that the status quo should be maintained. Singapore, namely pedra brancapulau batu puteh, middle rocks and. The dispute settled by the present judgment principally concerns sovereignty over the island of pedra branca pulau batu puteh, at issue between malaysia and singapore, and, less directly, sovereignty, in contention between the same two states, over two maritime features of minor importance near the aforementioned island, middle rocks and. Download pdf territorial disputes of the philippines free. The tiny island of pedra branca, where singapore administers a lighthouse, sits at the entrance to the singapore strait about 30 km 19 miles east of. Pedra branca pulau batu puteh also had sovereignty over middle rocks. The international court of justice ruled in 2008 that pedra branca, which means white rock in portuguese, belonged to singapore and a nearby feature called middle rocks belonged to malaysia.
Summaries of judgments, advisory opinions and orders of. Download pdf territorial disputes of the philippines. Pedra branca, the portugese term for white rock, hence serves two important functions as a herald of disputes and landmine of resources. Pedra branca pulau batu puteh is a granite island, measuring 7 m long, with an average. Ministry of defence mindef the singapore armed forces saf army, navy, air force potential enemies are deterred from invading singapore diplomacy. The pedra branca dispute was a territorial dispute between singapore and malaysia over several islets at the eastern entrance to the singapore strait, namely pedra branca, middle rocks and south ledge. Case concerning sovereignty over pedra brancapulau batu. Disputes between states on issues of law of the sea cannot be resolved by a court or tribunal unless both states consent modes of consent. This thesis examines four cases of maritime dispute resolution. Why did malaysia stop its appeal on the pedra branca case. On august 1, the malaysian government inaugurated a new maritime base near pedra branca, an outlying island that is now under the jurisdiction of neighboring singapore but. Pedra branca is avanco s second and much larger project, located 50km straight line southwest of the producing antas mine. Malaysia closes pedra branca case, so singapore team goes drinking to drown sorrows, publishes a book. Ministry of foreign affairs mfa builds good relations with.
Malaysia reveals new maritime base near disputed island. Malaysias application for revision of the pedra branca judgment. Scmp further said malaysias new evidence hangs on a letter by a singapores top colonial official in 1958, a naval incident reports the same year and a map of the lion city in 1966. The island consists of a small outcrop of granite rocks with an area of about 8,560 square metres 92,100 sq ft. The malaysians knew that their chances of winning the case were remote. The case was formally registered by the icj as the case concerning sovereignty over pedra brancapulau batu puteh, middle rocks and south ledge malaysiasingapore. Malayan railway ktm land in singapore and ciq 109 3. Optional clause declaration under article 36 of the icj statute 3. The dispute over pedra branca pulau batu puteh crystallized in feb ruary 1980, when singapore protested the publication by malaysia of a map showing the disputed island lying within malaysias territorial sea. Stream tracks and playlists from pedra branca on your desktop or mobile device. Malaysias application for revision of the pedra branca. The pedra branca dispute was a territorial dispute between singapore and malaysia over several islets at the eastern entrance to the singapore strait, namely pedra branca previously called pulau batu puteh and now batu puteh by malaysia, middle rocks and south ledge. Timeline of malaysiasingapore territorial dispute over pedra branca, middle rocks and south ledge. Pedra branca dispute reveals disconnect between malaysia.
South ledge is situated 4 km south of pedra branca. It determined that the sovereignty of middle rocks passed to the sultan of jahor and. While it is in the interests of the current malaysian government to ght against the apparent misappropriation of its territory, it has a. Pedra branca went to singapore, middle rocks went to malaysia, south ledge went to the lawyers. Connection timeout the pedra branca dispute was a territorial dispute between singapore and malaysia over several islets at the eastern entrance to the singapore strait, namely pedra branca previously called pulau batu puteh and now batu puteh by malaysia, middle rocks and south ledge. Public hearings on the merits of the dispute to open on tuesday 6. Gleaning lessons from dispute over pedra branca, singapore. Sovereignty over pedra brancapulau batu puteh, middle rocks and sou. Part of the chinese sailing instructions for the south china sea based on information compiled by admiral zheng he 711433 advised a navigator that after departing long ya men mandarin for dragons teeth gate, a rocky outcrop at the gateway to what is now keppel harbour in singapore, he should steer a course of between 75 and 90. World heritage encyclopedia, the aggregation of the largest online encyclopedias available, and the most definitive collection ever assembled. The court decided that the sovereignty of middle rocks was not dependent on the status of pedra branca pulau batu puteh. This is a very interesting account of the singapore side of the story of how the case with malaysia concerning the sovereignty over pedra branca, a tiny island strategically located near the entrance to the straits of malacca, went to the international court of justice icj. The international court of justice decision on the dispute between singapore and malaysia over the islet of pedra branca was broadcast live on friday 23 may over channel newsasia.
1576 1526 958 734 316 1306 1649 1129 767 1199 1345 1357 1430 511 1098 1183 411 915 963 433 1656 536 1448 86 1290 853 1527 1534 276 529 546 418 593 886 1356 118 134 929 1310 601 532